Oakland Historical Society [NJ]
Contact Us
  • Home
  • About
    • The Van Allen House—“Oakland’s Contribution to America’s Heritage”
  • Upcoming Events + Community Historians
  • Local History Collections
    • Images
    • Publications
    • Maps
    • The Streamhouse
  • Membership + Volunteers
  • Contact Us

Yeah, that Happens…

11/4/2025

 
Picture

Have You Gone to the “Ballot Box,” Yet?

11/1/2025

 
Picture
Ballot boxes are nearly as old as democracy itself. Some of the earliest evidence of casting ballots into a container date to the later Roman republic, when public voice-voting was replaced by anonymous ballots (then wax-covered boxwood tablets marked with a stylus) dropped into sealed urns. Our own American methods of voting began similarly with voice-votes and was replaced with ballots cast into sealed containers—but who could vote, and how, evolved even further and sometimes slid backwards.

In Colonial America voting in 12 of the 13 Colonies was restricted to white men who owned property—whether that property was land, silver and gold, jewelry, ships and cargo, or (horrifically) enslaved people. 

But if you lived in New Jersey you experienced voting as no other Colony did. From New Jersey’s first Constitution in 1776 "all inhabitants" who met the property-owning qualifications could vote—including women as well as any African American, Native American, and other persons “of color.” 


Opening opportunities to vote regardless of gender or ethnicity is thought to have been influenced by two dominant cultures in the State: the Dutch influence in the North, and the Quaker influence in the South. Both of these cultures treated women and people of color as equals—providing equal opportunities in education and business and allowing women to retain property in their own name upon marriage. (Unlike the English system where all of a woman’s property, including children, became her husband’s “property.”) Dutch and Quaker women owned property, ran businesses, made wills, signed contracts, and retained their maiden names upon marriage, and even carved them on their tombstones. And people of color, as long as they were free, could also own property, conduct business, and vote. 

And they did.

But some challenged the intentions of the 1776 State Constitution. So, when in 1790 New Jersey drafted a law to clarify who could vote, it referred to the State’s voters specifically as "he or she" and again in 1797 as “[voters should] openly and in full view deliver his or her ballot.”

And they continued to vote.

Taverns often served as a community’s natural gathering spot where news, gossip, and business flowed as freely as the libations. So, taverns were natural polling places as well. And all those who voted on election day were required to sign-in at the poll list first, as we still do today. Although only a precious few survive, poll lists record the names and places where qualified men and women of all ethnicities signed-in to vote.

Early deeds across the state also record women and people of color owning real estate. By cross-referencing these records to the poll lists, a researcher can get a more complete picture of who owned property at the time. (An ongoing project at the New Jersey State Archives is indexing all early land records, more than 80,000, held at the archives. The database can be filtered by gender and ethnicity, https://wwwdnet-dos.nj.gov/DOS_ArchivesDBPortal/EarlyLandRecords.aspx)

And they continued own property and vote.

By the turn of the century in 1800, it has been estimated by scholars that nearly 25% of the electorate was non-male and/or non-white. Growing political tensions across the state led to rumors of undue influence and the purchase of votes driven by political parties—and cries of “voter fraud” fell disproportionately on women, recent immigrants, and people of color. In 1807, political party tensons grew to a fever-pitch and a new law restricted voting to only “free, white males,” thus disenfranchising a significant portion of eligible voters until the 20th century.

But they continued to vote. 

Rumors and stories of newly disenfranchised people showing up to vote permeated folklore and contemporary newspaper tidbits through the early 1800s. Some reports were probably factual, and protests by the newly-disenfranchised, but other, more wild stories, were almost certainly fearmongering placed by political factions.

In 1880, Tenafly, New Jersey, resident Elizabeth Cady Staton, walked into her local polling place and demanded to be able to cast a vote—as her State foremothers had done before her—before being turned away. (Susan B. Anthony was born into a New York State Quaker family committed to social equality. She received an education equal to her male counterparts and cast a vote in Rochester, New York, in 1872. Unlike Stanton, Anthony was arrested for trying to vote.)

New Jersey Quaker and suffragette Alice Paul picked up Stanton and Anthony’s fight, seeing it through to the passage of the 19th Amendment in August 1920.

About the Ballot Box in Our Collection
This ballot box is most likely from the early 1900s and may have been used in party primaries. Although more than 100 years old, the box appears to be made of oak and is still incredibly sturdy—with reinforced frosted glass on four sides, a double top cover, and three locks to secure its contents. Although you’ve probably never had to use one, the idea of the ballot box is familiar to nearly everyone—surviving in lore if not reality and with a style and shape that is still replicated.

Although you’ve probably never had to use one, the idea of the ballot box is familiar to nearly everyone—surviving in lore if not reality and with a style and shape that is still replicated.

Now, get out there and cast your VOTE!

—--
Further Reading on Voting in New Jersey
In 2020, The Museum of the American Revolution (M*AR) in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, mounted “When Women Lost the Vote: A Revolutionary Story, 1776–1807,” an amazing exhibit about New Jersey and the women and people of color who exercised their legal right to vote. Included in the exhibit were the original 1776 and 1807 New Jersey State Constitutions and the 1790 election law that specified “he or she” all on special loan from the New Jersey State Archives. Additionally, the Bergen County Historical Society loaned an original 1700s tavern sign. 

While no 1776–1807 poll lists from Bergen County have yet been identified, 18 lists from other New Jersey counties were rediscovered in archives and loaned to the exhibit. Scholars at the museum conducted genealogical research into many of the names appearing in them—telling some of the stories of the 163 women identified on the 18 poll lists in the online exhibit.

Because the pandemic affected the ability to see the exhibit in-person, the M*AR created a comprehensive online exhibit for all to explore, amrevmuseum.org/virtualexhibits/when-women-lost-the-vote-a-revolutionary-story

It is worth a deep dive into all the corners of this incredibly interesting online exhibit.

—--
I wrote an article about the M*AR exhibit for the Genealogical Society of Bergen County newsletter as well as a bit more about the history and other online exhibits, njgsbc.org/wp-content/uploads/GSBC-The-Archivist-v47-n3-4-August-November-2020-NJ-SUFFRAGE.pdf

—--
Before his passing, former President of the Bergen County Historical Society Kevin Wright wrote about Elizabeth Cady Stanton’s 1880 vote in Tenafly. The research was conducted in an effort to save the historic building where the polling took place but, unfortunately, that fight was lost. gardenstatelegacy.com/assets/files/Elizabeth_Cady_Stanton_in_Tenafly_Wright_GSL47.pdf

—--
As we refresh the exhibits in the Oakland History Museum at the Van Allen House, we will look further into this artifact and share with you what we discover. 

Also in our collection are two mid-century steel ballot transport boxes from southern New York State. We’ll work to returning these to their rightful County and share updates when it happens.

Join us at our next monthly open house event and come see the ballot boxes in person! Check our website for details: https://oaklandhistoricalsociety.weebly.com
​

— Michelle D. Novak, MI; Archivist, Oakland Historical Society

Note: Occasional corrections and additions may be made to this post to improve accuracy.

—--
P.S. The New Jersey State Archives shared the following presentation on voting in New Jersey, enjoy!

New Jersey State Archives
This Election Day, find out whether you could vote during different time periods throughout New Jersey’s history! You can see how suffrage rights have evolved for New Jersey citizens over the last three centuries by viewing on a desktop browser here: https://prezi.com/view/QmE4afyNGu0QbC0nHG4y/

    Authors

    We have invited various residents (past and present) to share in their knowledge of Oakland's history.  We hope you enjoy learning more about your town! 

    Categories

    All
    Agriculture
    Bergen County History
    Early American History
    Northwest Bergen History Day
    Oakland History
    Oakland's Street Names
    OHS Events
    OHS Oakland History Museum

    Archives

    September 2026
    August 2026
    June 2026
    May 2026
    April 2026
    March 2026
    February 2026
    January 2026
    November 2025
    October 2025
    March 2021
    January 2020
    March 2019
    January 2019
    May 2017
    March 2017
    February 2015
    November 2014
    April 2014
    August 2013

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.